OLPC Dissapointments
Originally published at Valefor. You can comment here or there.
I’m getting disappointed reading the current news coming out of the OLPC camp. The reason I supported the project (and forked over my $400) was for two reasons. 1) I agree with education being the answer to most of the world’s problems and 2) I support open software. This project seemed to endorse both. I feel like both are deeply ingrained within each other. Not only does open software allow for creating awesome machines that are going to be usable for years without corporate lock in, but they also provide a learning experience for everyone regardless or age due to the nature of being able to play and pick apart the machine.
Hearing that the goal for the OLPC project is now to “get the technology in the hands of as many children as possible” I find myself disgusted. From the beginning it wasn’t a “laptop” project but a “education” project. That was stated so many times at talks over the past few years. Now all that has gone away. I’m totally fearful that this is just going to be another corporate sponsored “lock in another generation to our software” project. The world doesn’t need this. The world needs what OLPC was.
I hope the OLPC leaders listen to arguments like these. You aren’t helping anyone by spending money to help Microsoft get XP onto low power laptops. It’s wrong on so many levels. These kids need to be able to explore these systems and learn.
Even more important though is the apparent lack of my number one reason to be interested in the project. EDUCATION should be the primary concern, Not the spreading of technology. If the goal of the project is suddenly to only provide technology then I agree with all of the original naysayers: the money would better be spent on nutrition and poverty projects.
