Home
Earl Mardle's Journal
Thursday, May 29th, 2003

Date:2003-05-29 07:53
Subject:So Much for Convergence
Security:Public

Remember in the heady days of the Dotcom bubble when "new media" and "old media" were supposed to converge, creating and explosion of, well something, mostly profits?

Seems like the biggest attempt to converge the two is not working out anywhere near what was planned, or at least expected. AOL Spinoff May Be Back on Table

"There is still a wait-and-see attitude about the merger paying off the way it was supposed to do," UBS Warburg analyst Christopher Dixon told the E-Commerce Times. "They've done more in terms of cross-platform work lately, but the question is still out there, and it's a matter of time before AOL has to show progress or admit it might need to rethink where it's headed."

I still say that the main reason for this failure is that AOL is not at all a content business. because it attempts to be not only the source of connectivity, but also to keep its users on its own networks (many AOL users have never used the Internet, only AOL services and content) it has had to develop those services and that content itself or through commercial partnerships. It flies in the face of what the Internet actually is, a vast source of information, content, services, all built on its End to End structure.

Unfortunately AOL, and many others, thinks that End to End means that they have to own the process "from one end to the other". They couldn't have been more wrong. Merging AOL and TW made about as much sense a merging a trucking firm and a cake shop because the cake shop does deliveries.

The media business model is this "I sell my audience's wallets to my advertising customers", the ISP business is "I sell ends of connectivity". The first sucks up human resources like crazy, the second is rapidly becoming a commodity business. There is no point of connection.

In Australia, Telstra is moving out of the content business because its expensive and doesn't attract enough new customers looking for "high quality content" on their network. Big surprise. Education is occurring.

post a comment



Date:2003-05-29 08:17
Subject:Catching Up
Security:Public

Here are the Postings for January, 2003.

Network drivers in Bankruptcies and Deflation Talk

Elliot Wave Theory - A Measure of Emergence

Anything Works Unless Everyone Does it

Lying; The New Competitive Advantage

Hollywood Should Be More Careful of the Emergence It is Driving

Golden Rice Better Than Expected and Open Source

Managerial Aggression Breaks the Contract

Emergent Processes and Enormous Leverage

OK, How Did the Ants Figure THIS Out?

Copyright War: Another Round to Consumer Control

Copyright War: IP Control Freaks Lose Another 2 Rounds

Music Industry sees Small Glimmer of Light

No Need for a Conspiracy When You Own the System

How do New Norms Supersede the Old? Its the Internet Stupid

You WILL Watch The Adverts

When 25% is Still "Under the Radar"

We Media - Interactive Internet Journalism Is Already Here

Predictions - Getting Emergence Before it Shows ..

Not Your Father's Economy

Maybe Birds Started Out Trying to Stick to the Earth

How Many Homes Have to Burn ...

Innovation, You CAN'T Stop It

The Higher the profile, the Worse the Business

Eldred v Ashcroft - Corporate America Pulls Its Memes Out of the Pool

Music Industry Has no Shame

Lord Mayor Of London Tries to Find a Tipping Point

Integrated Text-Based Communications Tool

The Network is Too damned Smart

Emergent Geometry

Dana Blankenhorn Says Its A Boycott - Emergent of Course

The Proliferation of Great Ideas

THIS is what I mean by a Knowledge Economy

Language, Not Only Emergent, But Sudden and Subject to Power laws

Cloning is an Emergent Process, not a Photocopier

Ming Quotes Bucky on an Emergent Universe

a Wonder of Reconciliation

MS SQL Worm

Doing the Numbers on Copyright Violations

Merging Microbes Precede Gene Therapy by Millions of Years

post a comment


browse days
my journal