Writer's Block: Health Care
I usually don't bother with these but the phrasing of this one intrigued me. "Is" indicates the state of health care at this moment in time. What
is health care at this moment in time? In America at least it is a privilege. But then we have the awkward "to you" at the end of the question. In reality, health care isn't anything
to me. It can't be. It is a concept. Concepts cannot affect me in reality. To phrase the question in a manner that directs it at the current state of affairs, it probably should have ended with "for you". However, that is not the questioner's intent here. In reality, I believe they are asking what health care
should be in a more perfect world in the future as it is impossible to alter the state of the world in this moment. It is only possible to implement changes now that will alter the state of the world in the future.
Altering the phrasing slightly, we have "
Should health care
be a right or a privilege to you?"
But wait. To me? Hell, if
I'm the only one I'm concerned about, of course it should be a right! Again, is this really what the original questioner intended? I doubt it. So we truly need to drop the final prepositional phrase.
"Should health care be a right or a privilege?"
Ah, there we go.
Tags: writer's block Current Mood: 
sleepy