Utterances Acquaintances Calendar About jonnynexus.com That Way That Way This Way This Way
Planet Jonny - Ah! So That's Why This Story Has Died
jonnynexus
[info]jonnynexus
Add to Memories
Tell a Friend
Ah! So That's Why This Story Has Died
It's because:
Twenty-four later, the Mirror and all other British papers had been subjected to a "gag order" under Section 5 the Official Secrets Act at pain of prosecution.

http://www.counterpunch.org/heard11232005.html
Ah, the old Official Secrets Act maneuver! Classic!

So does that mean I'm breaking some kind of law by mentioning what the actual story is? Oh, bugger it, here goes...
"The gag by the Attorney General Lord Goldsmith" the same attorney general who changed his pre-Iraq War legal opinion after being badgered by US government lawyers to do so "came nearly 24 hours after the Mirror informed Downing Street of its intention to reveal how Tony Blair talked Bush out of attacking satellite station Al Jazeera's HQ in friendly Qatar" in the spring of 2004.
How serious an allegation is this? Well as the article goes on to say:
Imagine that the free world's top dog ostensibly out to promote democracy, freedom and 'our way of life' - whatever that is - wants to bomb an independent television station on the soil of one of its closest allies, owned by the ruler of that allied country.

What are the implications for journalists that refuse to toe the coalition line? What about free speech and freedom of the press issues?

But the most worrying question is this: If the alleged bombing of Al Jazeera had gone ahead, with consequent deaths and injuries, wouldn't this equate the US administration with the terrorism it purports to hate?

Excuse the repetition but I would like to stress that Al Jazeera is owned by an ally of the US and staffed with respected editors and journalists from around the world, including many who formerly worked for the BBC.

These people are not terrorists or insurgents; they are not uniformed military or intelligence personnel. They are simply people trying to tell it like it is in an environment plagued by censorship, and judging by Al Jazeera's 50 million regular viewers and the ire they provoke from regional governments, they are doing something right.
Yeah, but the story's probably bollocks, right? Well as the article also points out:
The White House has characterized the Mirror's reporting as "outlandish", but if that's the case, one wonders why Downing Street has gone into crisis mode not only prosecuting two of its own civil servants David Keogh and Leo O'Connor under the Official Secrets Act but also threatening editors of British newspapers with prosecution an historical first according to Richard Taylor-Norton of the Guardian.

So while Bush is attempting to brush off the incident, the British government is appearing more as though it has its hand in the cookie jar with damage control its first priority.

When asked to comment on the memo Downing Street refused to do so saying it doesn't commented on leaked documents. Be that as it may - and provided the Mirror story is false - then, surely, an absolute denial by the Prime Minister would put the story to bed and quash the rumors.
It does all look a tad dodgy.
Comments
From: [info]cp_evilref Date: November 24th, 2005 03:37 pm (UTC) (Link)
Nothing that I could see on the BBC about it, but that's unsurprising given the penalties for breaking a D notice are huge. It's also interesting that the downing street memo (about the us having planned to go to war long before they did) wasn't d'noticed but this is. Could be because the leak included intelligence information, sources or suchlike though.
matgb From: [info]matgb Date: November 24th, 2005 07:48 pm (UTC) (Link)
Boris says:
If someone passes me the document within the next few days I will be very happy to publish it in The Spectator, and risk a jail sentence. The public need to judge for themselves. Sunlight is the best disinfectant. If we suppress the truth, we forget what we are fighting for, and in an important respect we become as sick and as bad as our enemies.

Thx for the counterpunch link Jonny, useful.
former_pirate From: [info]former_pirate Date: November 25th, 2005 07:57 am (UTC) (Link)
In defence of the D-notice, I will point out that, while weighty, they are voluntary. So an editor can go "fuck it, this is more important than that". They would have to be pretty sure they were right, of course.

And of course, for D-notices to work, the security services have to be careful not to misuse them. If they were to use them frivolously, they would lose all meaning and everyone would just disregard them.

I'd rather have D-notices than actual, legally enforced, gag orders. Whether or not the government are correct in invoking the Official Secrets Act here, we can't know without seeing the document. It's obviously not the story of Bush wanting to bomb al-Jazeera that's of concern, as that's already out.
3 thoughts or Leave a thought
Profile
jonnynexus
Name: jonnynexus
About Me
Jonny Nexus is thought by many to be the leading humour writer on the subject of roleplaying games.

He's served as a regular columnist for the magazines Valkyrie and Signs & Portents, wrote the Slayers Guide to Games Masters for leading gaming company Mongoose Publishing, and is the editor and chief writer of the cult webzine Critical Miss.

He's now written the rather spiffy and ENnie nominated novel Game Night. If you liked Critical Miss, you'll love Game Night.



Outside of writing, he lives in West London with his wife and works as a programmer in the City of London. "Jonny Nexus" is, of course, a pseudonym.

You can subscribe to Planet Jonny by either RSS or email.

 Subscribe in a reader

Enter your email address:


Delivered by FeedBurner

Calendar
Back September 2008
123456
78910111213
14151617181920
21222324252627
282930
Links
Page Summary
Tags