Home

Fri, May. 27th, 2005, 11:42 am
"Why are you so far away?"

The observation has been widely made that people are drifting apart. That despite all the technology designed to make communication easier, we share ourselves less and less. That community is dead, and each man has become a fortress unto himself.

We've heard a zillion theories about why this is. Blame has been thrown in a zillion directions. "Internet friendships aren't real." "Email is so impersonal." "We use the telephone as an excuse not to meet face to face." We blame population, youth, age, politics, people being too different from each other, people being too much the same... it seems everyone has a pet theory.

I blame advertising.

Telemarketers own your phone. Caller ID exists because half the calls you get are strangers trying to sell you something.

Spam owns your email. Every time you check your email you're waltzing through a minefield.

Even in meatspace, when your doorbell rings you have to steel yourself to fend off salesmen, canvassers, and evangelists.

Junk mail has outweighed real mail for a long time, there are ads printed on every flat surface, and now you're even paying to see ads at the movies. Remember when nothing played on the big screen before the movie but a couple of trailers?

We've been trained to think of this stuff as a mere annoyance, nothing more than an eyesore. But I've recently come to realize that we're actually being hurt by it. Why? Because advertising fucks with your head. Deliberately. Aggressively. Advertising is no longer merely ugly or discourteous. It has become actively malicious.

Spam is the prime example. Merely by trying to bypass automatic filters, spammers have created an atmosphere of hostility; you have declared, by filtering, that you don't wish to recieve their communication, and rather than respecting that, they have put an enormous amount of ingenuity into bulling past your defenses. This is an attack. It is hostile. But what's worse, some of their methods are intended to trick not only your filters, but you yourself. Subject lines intended to sound like a coworker or a friend with urgent business. Faked return addresses that masquerade as well-known online businesses. Outright fraud, password-fishing expeditions disguised as financial statements or even scare-letters about your eBay and Amazon accounts. Lies. Cruel lies. Mindgames. Emotional assault.

It's not just spam. In snailmail, credit card offers now come disguised as bills. Insurance ads come disguised as magazine billing statements. Phone solicitors pretend you called them first, or refer to your fictitious previous business. Junk faxers use up your ink and paper with 'Here's the info you asked for!' Lies and mindgames.

So now we can't trust our legitimate correspondence either. Maybe it's only a split-second doubletake, or maybe you have to give it some serious thought, but every honest message you recieve has to undergo a moment's distrust. Is it any wonder that atmosphere of besieged paranoia has bled over into all our communication? Advertising has destroyed our trust in each other more than bad government or weird religion ever has. At least when the government tells you of its latest bad policy decision, it doesn't do so by sending you an email with the title, "Bill, I have to tell you a secret."

Fri, May. 27th, 2005 10:16 pm (UTC)
[info]seebs

We get credit card offers which have a fake card in 'em. It's a piece of plastic the right shape to be a credit card, with writing on it.

Better yet, the envelope has a sort of scraped outline that looks a bit like an impression of a card on the front, as though there were a card in it and the bumps on the card made ink rub off on it.

To add insult to injury: The envelope's markings are clearly correct for a card (four groups of digits in the right size, lettering below) but indistinct... And the card inside the envelope just has a single line of writing on it.

In other words, the thing that looks a bit like a carbon-copy impression of a card is entirely fake. Just to make you open the letter and see what this card is.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 07:02 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

Makes you wonder who actually responds to those. Doesn't being tricked usually make people angry?

Fri, May. 27th, 2005 10:16 pm (UTC)
[info]alisgray

really? I blame war of worldcraft.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 07:01 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

*snerk*

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 12:06 am (UTC)
[info]jlick

Instant messaging is also polluted with hot young girls that want to chat with me. It's getting to the point where it's only safe to communicate with a small group of friends or you'll get pestered to death.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 07:02 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

How can the girls not adore you, with a sexxay icon like that? :D

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 03:05 am (UTC)
radparker

I do understand how frustrating the deluge of advertising can be. Especially slimy/unethical advertising. Been fighting the spam fight for years, personally. Have had telemarketer block on my phone for years.

But it feels like a bit of a cop out to me to blame the lack of inteconnectedness you feel on advertising. I would suggest that perhaps instead you need to look at how to find, build, join, and/or participate in communities, both online or offline.

My personal experience is that connecting to people depends on you as a person and your ability to connect, rather than the medium by which you try to connect. Annoyance by spam only erodes your ability to connect to somebody by email (perhaps...not sure that I even agree to that). But if worrying about a credit card offer looking like a statement or a piece of spam tricks you into opening it, if that stops you from talking to other people or connecting with them, then are you sure that there isn't an underlying phobia or issue that is really driving that?

Advertising doesn't stop you from meeting your friends in person. From joining a church or community service group. From building your circle of friends on LiveJournal. From joining and participating in discussion email lists about subjects you're interested in. Etc. etc.

I just drove about 1700 miles and back to visit friends that I haven't seen in five years, btw. I'm definitely got my own communication (and other) deficiencies, but I'm still able to connect with others.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 06:44 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

Of course. I was certainly not arguing that it's impossible to have friends. Nor was I complaining about a personal lack of connectedness.

Rather, I was pointing out a general sense of distrust that's seeping into many of our forms of communication. I'm not saying it's not great to get a call from a friend; I'm saying having to check the caller ID first every time can't help but taint the experience, which is something I think we could all do without. Just as having to have six locks on your apartment door creates a sense of distrust within the building, however much you might like your next-door neighbor specifically.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 03:37 am (UTC)
[info]draxienne: Thanks for inspiring rambling.

My theory is that people feel too important. Their life, their problems, their little heartaches, everything gets blown out of proportion. Cause, we want that attention, we see so many people on the TV whose every move is followed my watchful eyes, whose emotions are branded into our hearts with the hot iron of gossip magazines (and even if you don't read them, SOMEHOW, it will reach you, that there are people out there who matter, who are "just like you and me", and everyone knows them.) And aren't our own problems just as exciting? And a bit exaggeration here and there never hurt anyone.

And with everyone feeling like they deserve more than they have, everyone becomes cold and alone. :(

I mean, I see it all the time. I know people who really don't buy into the shitty media world, and you know what? They have a large community of friends, they have people they trust, because they don't want to be more than they are. People like me, who take themselves serious (far too serious) will die bitter and alone. I don't make friends... because the pain when they hurt me, or when I hurt them would be terrifying. But would it really? Or am I just telling this myself, don't trust people, or your whole life will be ruined?

I believe ads have a part in the feeling important, too. YOU need this and that, YOU have been chosen, blah blah. If even the ads notice us, we can't be so small and unimportant, right?

The world needs more humbleness, and more hardworking, down-to-earth Christians. You can say about them what you like, but the nicest and most popular people I know are Christians. Not fundies, no Jack Chick nuts. Just people who pray before they eat, and before they go to bed, who go to church every sunday, and return refreshed and inspired.

'Course, I'm lazy, and friends mean work, so I'm not about to compromise my huge bloated ego just for some friends who steal all my time. Not to mention all the social contact would drive me nuts. I just don't feel like connecting to people.

Maybe that is a problem, too, that no one wants it. I don't know, I'm not normal, I don't know how much social contact a normal person can take. Two successive days of family trips, and you'll have a hard time getting me out of my room for weeks =/

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 06:50 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan: Re: Thanks for inspiring rambling.

I'm thoroughly social-phobic, actually, so I know where you're coming from. I need tons and tons of alone-time to deal with even my closest friends. I can't help but wonder, though, if I'd be more social with them if they were the only ones contacting me.

The sense of entitlement you describe seems to me to come from a strange combination of low self-esteem and overattention. Rather than feeling important, I think people feel UNimportant, yet constantly scrutinized. Surveilled, rather than appreciated. And so they demand constant reassurance and validation, not because they think they're all that, but because they're terrified every moment they've got it wrong.

It takes a magnificent bastard to not care if he's got it wrong. I still aspire. :D

I think you're right about the causes, though. Advertising and media bombard us with feel-good messages that are quite deliberately narrow misses. They're almost talking to you, but not quite -- and this creates an urge to adapt to the message so they will be talking to you. It's the same thing as how most people, if you stare just to the side of their face while addressing them, will move into your field of vision rather than demanding that you look straight at them.

Sun, May. 29th, 2005 02:44 am (UTC)
[info]draxienne: Re: Thanks for inspiring rambling.

Hmmm, true. Maybe both?

Those that suffer from low self-esteem feel unimportant, and watched, those who have high self-esteem feel important and neglected. No one is really confident with what he is.

I come from the high self-esteem corner myself (haven't quite managed the art of the magnificant bastardness yet, but I think I get pretty close - at least on the outside.)

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 04:56 am (UTC)
[info]sockschan

It's an excellent point about hostile advertising and distance. Advertising fscks us over in other ways too, mostly by reinforcing in our minds that we are not l33t, we are not cool, we are not what we should be - and that the only path to that heaven is through TheProduct. We work and work and work so that we have money to consume, to buy, to spend on becoming better. No one ever stops to think, "I'm fine the way I am." They are never happy, never satisfied, and they live and die on the hamster wheel of consumerism.

But we've let that happen to a certain extent. Eleanor Roosevelt said, "No one can make you feel inferior without your own consent." It's all true. We LET advertising fuck with our heads, we LET ourselves become paranoid. We allow the Fifth Avenue Fuckers to screw us over, to run our lives.

When you're so concerned with yourself (and this is a general you, not addressing you personally, [info]gomichan, or anyone else here) and what's wrong with you, what you're lacking, then of course you cannot properly connect to another human being. Your standards are skewed by those marketing meatheads, and even if that weren't the case, you're so convinced that you are not worthy that any relationship you do miraculously wind up in is doomed from the start by your (and possibly your partner's) constant need for self- and re-assurance. (whoosh - run-on sentences are fun, boys and girls!)

"One must learn to judge things via the perceived truths that one receives from others." People need to take control of their lives again, and learn to critically judge all incoming data, whether that be spam and junk mail or even just the attitudes and opinions of other people. Ask yourself, "Is this really true, and if it is, why?" Seek out what makes you happy and shun what doesn't. "Work from love. Grow from love. Screw the world." ^_~

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 06:57 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

This is all true, but human beings have limits. We now have to exercise our critical judgement on every incoming stimulus, and we're barraged with stimuli every day. We spend so much energy sorting the signal from the noise that there's none left for appreciating what we end up keeping when the sorting's done.

There are foods we don't eat because they require too much processing for too little nutrition. Jokes we don't tell because there's too much setup for not enough punchline. Thanks to the flood tide of advertising we deal with every day, communication is becoming like that too.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 07:07 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

Incidentally, where'd you get that icon? I see them all over, but no one will tell me where they come from.

Sun, May. 29th, 2005 02:11 am (UTC)
[info]sockschan

Friend made it for me. I forget where he found the original that he modified for me. If I find it, I'll try to remember to shoot you the link.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 09:03 am (UTC)
[info]pussinboots

Even though this is only mildly related, I have to share this tip for getting rid of fax spam.

Fax them back fifteen copies of a black piece of paper. :) Works like a *charm.*

Also, I get rid of my porn spam by tracking down the actual address the mail came from and telling them I am underage and that my dad is a lawyer.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 06:58 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

Seebs has an even better way of dealing with junk faxers: sue their asses for every penny the law allows. He does it just for fun; he gives the money away. He just likes to see the bitches cry. :D :D :D

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 11:14 am (UTC)
(Anonymous)

You are so right about this.
I myself have stopped anwering my home telephone completly, because of all the junk calls. The phone scares me. I don't want to buy stuff, I want to speak to my friends, but now they can't reach me any more.
It makes me paranoid and has given me a very negative view on communication.

- Åsa (random fan of your blog (specially your points on yaoi) and Metanoia comic)

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 06:58 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

You've pretty much condensed my entire point into a few concise sentences. Many thanks!

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 03:56 pm (UTC)
[info]kehrli

I agree with you entirely, which is why I consider myself to be the only real "sell-out" writer I know - since I make all my money writing advertising bullshit for companies that sell shit - or even worse for companies that make all THEIR money from advertising for other advertisements...

There are some google search strings that will only return websites with ads and links to other ad-laden websites. @__@

The internet is one big advertisement.

Sat, May. 28th, 2005 07:00 pm (UTC)
[info]gomichan

The world is one big advertisement. It's hard not to feel like a wallet on legs.

You do what you gotta do to put food on the table, but man, I can see why you want to get out of that racket. Here's my fingers crossed for you to get many tech writing gigs and suchlike.