Design and Theory
May. 3rd, 2007 | 04:29 pm
music: Beethoven, Grosse Fuge
If I wanted to comment on these threads directly, with reference to their original contexts and debates and personalities and whatnot, I’d do so at the Forge, breaking my self-imposed omerta (which is mostly a matter of lack of interest combined with lack of time). This is just my own weird take on the issues from what is perhaps a peculiar perspective.
What I will propose here is an alternative theoretical direction that may perhaps be of some service with reference to these difficulties. Please be aware that this post is VERY LONG.
Link | Leave a comment {12} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
My Goodness
Apr. 30th, 2007 | 11:12 pm
mood:
bouncy
I don't really know what to say.
Wow!
Hope they don't all hate it when they read it, whoever they are, is all I suppose I can say.
Jeepers.
Not that it has anything to do with gaming. I thought I was logged in on the other blog. Oh well, I know you all care too.
Link | Leave a comment {5} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
A GNS Question
Apr. 25th, 2007 | 10:26 pm
As I turn that over in my head, possibly profitably but possibly not, I have some questions for you. Please insert "and the Big Model" after GNS if that is helpful to you; I don't really care.
1. Do you find GNS useful in your current play?
2. Did you find it so in the past?
3. If you design games, do you think about this while you design (including general mulling over)?
4. Did you do so in the past?
5. Do you think that GNS should change and develop significantly?
6. Practically speaking, do you think it will change noticeably in the next year or so?
7. When you see someone make a GNS-based remark somewhere on the web, do you react with interest, annoyance, or what?
8. What is your overall assessment of what GNS has achieved in the past?
9. What is your assessment of its future?
You don't have to answer all that, obviously, but I am genuinely interested to know, as I see very, very different things about this.
Oh, one more thing: is it worth creating a poll like this? I've never done one.
Link | Leave a comment {12} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
More stories
Apr. 1st, 2007 | 11:01 pm
Start here with this link and read several pages of this stuff. This is quite raw data, direct from the Kwakiutl when they still existed in a fairly solid way. A word of advice: don't allegorize -- this material is a great deal more difficult to interpret than it looks, and as you'll see, that's saying something.
Link | Leave a comment {12} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Stories?
Mar. 31st, 2007 | 12:00 pm
Link | Leave a comment {44} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Spot That Thread!
Mar. 31st, 2007 | 12:02 am
Anyway, we also got into "brain damage," which was Ron Edwards' borrowing of sociobiological rhetoric for gaming. Many gamers are giving Ron a pass on this as some kind of metaphor, but he's made it clear he believes it's literally true and I figure he's following a doctrine of neural Darwinism in doing so. What he has not done, however, is identified what a story is in a sociobiological context, which makes his critique kind of halfassed, even within its own rules. So Ron would do well to give the whole "just so story" on the sociobiology of the Big Model, or else it's just the arbitrary invention I believe it to be -- but *by his own standards.*I don't read the Forge much these days, and I confess I don't know what Malcolm's referring to. It sounds fascinating. Anyone know the thread?
Link | Leave a comment {3} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Mysteries
Mar. 27th, 2007 | 02:11 pm
Link | Leave a comment {3} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Making Cultures: Chapter 2
Mar. 27th, 2007 | 12:31 pm
Link | Leave a comment {9} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Making Cultures: Chapter 1
Mar. 27th, 2007 | 12:26 pm
Chapter 1. First Principles: Sacred and Profane
I notice that religion is relatively often added late to fantasy worlds. It also seems to have consistent institutional and mythological forms: priests with temples dedicated to particular gods in a pantheon. Sometimes there is a significant attempt to integrate these into the game-world; more often, they seem tacked-on, something primarily the concern of religious professionals (clerics, druids, etc.).
All of this depends on a number of fundamental assumptions that are stunningly difficult for most modern Westerners to get around. And because these assumptions are so deep, and because they in some sense run right to the core of what we think culture is in the first place, I think the best way to start building something new and different is to challenge those assumptions.
Link | Leave a comment {7} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Making Cultures: Start of a long series
Mar. 27th, 2007 | 12:17 pm
Preface
Over the last few years, I have run into quite a number of discussions about how to design cultures for fantasy games. To me the most interesting of these have centered on questions like, “How do you design a fantasy culture so that it isn’t Eurocentric?” And I’ve posted bits and pieces of a personal response to such things, here and there, especially on The Forge but also in other places. I keep pushing around this notion that someday I’m really going to lay it all out in one place, clearly, from beginning to end.
Link | Leave a comment {20} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Hi Gang
Mar. 3rd, 2007 | 08:36 pm
Well, I'm not entirely sure I have re-surfaced. I am rather swamped by professional work, and a career that is finally developing somewhat in a good direction. You can expect to see the odd posting here, though -- I doubt I'll go a year of silence again in the near future, anyway.
I am currently working, very slowly, on some bits and pieces of a "how to design a fantasy culture from the ground up" thing, which will be a string of very long articles. In the process, I'm trying to teach some basics of some classics of the study of culture. Expect to see some piece of this within a month.
I notice I'm still listed on the Squidoos and whatnot, so presumably whoever cares will see this message.
See you all soon.
Link | Leave a comment {5} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Simulating Cultural Phenomena
Mar. 19th, 2006 | 02:07 pm
In designing RPG settings, especially "fantasy" worlds (whatever you take that to mean), to what extent, and for what purposes, should one work toward simulation of such cultural phenomena as religion, magic, and arts?
( Read more... )
Link | Leave a comment {31} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Prompted by John Kim on Magic and Science
Mar. 18th, 2006 | 12:09 am
I’m still working on the “how to design a fantasy religion” thing, but got a bit bogged down. Just this evening, however, I was re-reading John Kim’s Breaking Out of Scientific Magic Systems, and it sparked a couple of ideas.
This is all unrefined musings, of course....
( Read more... )
Link | Leave a comment {8} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
A Note on Evolution
Feb. 5th, 2006 | 10:42 pm
( Read more... )
Link | Leave a comment {8} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Back soon
Feb. 5th, 2006 | 10:28 pm
The religion thing is progressing apace. Expect a chapter in a week or so.
Link | Leave a comment | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Back from Xmas
Jan. 11th, 2006 | 11:40 pm
So, now that I'm back, a question for you all. I've been working slowly on two closely-related articles about designing cultures for fantasy RPGs. One is about culture in general, soup to nuts, and the other is about religion in particular. Both seem to be turning out exceedingly long, and that's not just because I'm long-winded: I find myself having to explain a lot of "first principles" because most of what academics who study this stuff -- particularly religion -- is so drastically at odds with the assumptions that underlie mainstream designs in RPGs.
Here's my question.
Does anyone care? I mean, if I post a 10-page chunk of a much longer article, will anyone actually read it?
I'll get back to the current running topics soon, I promise.
Link | Leave a comment {14} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
How do the 'Big' RPGs Really Work?
Dec. 22nd, 2005 | 04:54 pm
Link | Leave a comment {8} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
Article Link - Structure and Meaning in RPG Design
Dec. 22nd, 2005 | 03:24 am
( Read more... )
Link | Leave a comment {6} | Add to Memories | Tell a Friend
RPGs and Ideology?
Dec. 19th, 2005 | 08:43 pm
( Read more... )
